Ramblings of the Hooper Family RSS 2.0
# Tuesday, June 12, 2007

... and about 1 gallon of sweat -- and the dog's water dish.  More on that later.

As many of you know, our A/C went out downstairs last night (AGAIN!  3rd time this year) and I was going to try and fix it (or at least diagnose it) myself.  My prior workings on the A/C revealed that, at least electrically, A/C systems are actually extremely simple devices and I had confidence!

Goodman.B18099-13S

It started with Amy telling me around 7-ish that the thermostat was completely dead -- like it had no power.  She was right, there was no power (typically 24 VAC) going to the thermostat.  It was 7pm, so I figured I'd see what I could figure out.  After a simple check of the breaker, I went up into the attic, pulled the cover off the furnace and went to work with the multimeter (yes, the same one my Papa gave me about 20 years ago).  At first I suspected a fuse, but no, both were intact.  Then, maybe the transformer.  No, there was no power into the transformer.  I feared the main control board (pictured) was dead, but I found no power going to the board at all.  Then I suspected the door detection safety switch (which I was pushing over and over while doing all this testing).  Upon opening it up, I found no power going into the unit at all!  I went back downstairs to check the voltage coming off the breaker.  (This is when the dog's water dish was sacrificed.  I mistakenly thought I had two screws left, and the breaker panel cover fell to the floor, the dog's water dish breaking the fall in a spectacular explosion of plastic.)  Alas, the voltage coming off the breaker read live at 120V.  Huh?  The wires in the house aren't that old!

IMG_4927

Then I remembered there was actually a switch in the attic that could turn off the power to the A/C unit.  (Groan.)  Did a bird get in there and hit the switch?  A squirrel maybe?  I found the switch, and it was still on.  Despite my doubt that a physical switch (that gets used maybe once every 5 years) could be the root of the problem, I decided to check it out.  Upon pulling the cover off, a piece of plastic fell out.  Interesting.  When I took the switch out, I found a loose wire, not connected to anything.  Aha!  It turns out that the plastic at the back of the switch had cracked (probably upon the original installation) and the contact had completely fallen off (pictured).  The wire to the A/C had likely been just resting against the switch -- time and temperature fluctuations finally disconnecting it.  This is a good reminder NOT to insert wires into the back of the switch, but to use the screw terminals instead.  I raced to Home Depot (as they were about to close at 9pm), bought a new switch for $5.99 and raced home.  Once I installed the new switch, the problem was solved!

Update: Steve and Barbara Arnold have a A/C service website that is chock full of good information if you have A/C problems.  It's somewhat poorly organized and looks kinda 1990s style, but there's good information there and they sell parts for decent prices.  If you get a "pro" to work on your A/C, you might want to stop by this place if you're wondering whether you're getting what you're paying for.

Tuesday, June 12, 2007 10:38:43 AM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)  #    Comments [3] -
Ramblings
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 1:02:04 PM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)
Nice work. There's no telling how long that would have taken a repair man to figure out and fix, and no telling what they might have actually told you was wrong. I can almost picture this imaginary person's internal struggle... "What? the switch was broken? I've been up here for 2 hours. I gotta come up with something better than that... How about... Needs a whole new A/C! Yeah!"

It's one of the things that makes me glad I no longer have an A/C.
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 3:59:00 PM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)
Yeah, we've had a few people work on our A/C over the years, and what I've found is the typical path is to replace things in the order that they commonly fail. So my prediction would have been that he would replace the transformer ($15 + $100 labor), replace the secondary board ($100 + $150 labor), replace the furnace control board ($150 + $200 labor), then the safety switch ($2 + $100 labor). Hundreds of dollars later, "Call an electrician, there's still something wrong with your home's wiring."

A few weeks ago, the outdoor unit went out, and we had a guy come out to look at it. Overall, he was very competent and honest, but in addition to the $60 to come out and diagnose, he did charge $80 to replace a capacitor ($4 at Granger, and labor is ULTRA easy), and $250 to replace the fan motor ($40 at Granger). He wanted to charge an additional $150 to take the motor assembly to a machine shop to attempt to remove and salvage the fan blades (new ones $35 at Granger) but I drew the line there, paid the $60 and bought the 3 items at Granger, and installed them myself. Went ahead and boosted the power of that fan by about 50% while I was at it, which I really do think has resulted in cooler air coming from the vents. Tim Allen would be proud.

Of course, more power means that the fan blades needed to be attached a bit tighter to the motor shaft, and not doing that resulted in the 2nd A/C outage. Ooops.
Paul
Tuesday, June 12, 2007 9:50:29 PM (Central Daylight Time, UTC-05:00)
I just want to point out: Thank God that the dog's plastic water dish tower was NOT full at the time, or that would have been an even bigger mess!
Amy
Comments are closed.
Navigation
Archive
<July 2010>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
27282930123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031
1234567
Blogroll
About the author/Disclaimer

Disclaimer
The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions. They do not represent any employer, any other people, dead or alive, any mammal or group of mammals, and so on and so forth.

© Copyright 2010
Paul and Amy Hooper
Sign In
Statistics
Total Posts: 172
This Year: 7
This Month: 2
This Week: 0
Comments: 127
Themes
Pick a theme:
All Content © 2010, Paul and Amy Hooper
DasBlog theme 'Business' created by Christoph De Baene (delarou)